who is the old man with whom you were talking?当主句是以who或which开头的特殊疑问句时只能用that,但这个地方介词提前,所以用whom.这是否是矛盾.

来源:学生作业帮助网 编辑:作业帮 时间:2024/11/09 02:55:56

who is the old man with whom you were talking?当主句是以who或which开头的特殊疑问句时只能用that,但这个地方介词提前,所以用whom.这是否是矛盾.
who is the old man with whom you were talking?
当主句是以who或which开头的特殊疑问句时只能用that,但这个地方介词提前,所以用whom.这是否是矛盾.

who is the old man with whom you were talking?当主句是以who或which开头的特殊疑问句时只能用that,但这个地方介词提前,所以用whom.这是否是矛盾.
这句话可以写成:Who is the old man you were talking with?这样句子成分就很清晰了.为什么写成以上那样.

赞同一楼的说法

不矛盾。。。一个看着不是很顺眼的定语从句,同样的句型Mr. Smith is the person with whom I am working.

不矛盾,由“介词+关系代词”引导的定语从句,只能用which(指物)或whom(指人);主句是以who或which开头的特殊疑问句时只能用that,后半句缺少主语的情况下

与你谈话的那个老头是谁呀?(with whom是个介词短语,在后面的定语从句中做状语成份)